Best Caribbean Island for a Honeymoon

Jane Anderson, Honeymoon expertBy Jane Anderson, Editor

The 32-plus island nations of the Caribbean conjure images of white sand beaches, swaying palms and usually little else. But look closer and you’ll soon discover that the West Indies is a diverse region that suits not only honeymooners looking to fly and flop in paradise, but those seeking adventure, culture, inspiring cuisine and spas.

UPDATE: many Caribbean islands are on the Government’s Green List, including Anguilla, Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados, British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Dominica, Grenada and Turks & Caicos Islands. Cuba, Mexico and Dominican Republic are on the Red List.

Accommodation in the Caribbean comes in many forms including boutique, feet-in-the-sand boltholes, charming B&Bs, dive lodges, all-inclusive, private villas, sophisticated five-star resorts and high end private island retreats.

All are well versed in making honeymooners feel special – but make sure they know it’s your honeymoon in advance – and many have a sophisticated set up when it comes to weddings with co-ordinators on-hand to tailor-make your big day.

The key to getting your Caribbean wedding and honeymoon right is to choose the right island and the right resort for you. So you need to do some research such as speaking to a Caribbean specialist like Caribtours which has a wealth of advice on romantic places to stay, or Essential Detail which has picked 13 of the best small hotels and resorts in the Caribbean.

If you want a romantic couples-only all-inclusive resort you can’t beat Sandals which has hotels in St. Lucia, BarbadosJamaica, Grenada, Antiguaand the Bahamas. It offers free weddings and over-water suites as well as butler service plus gourmet dining and water sports all in the price.

Because of the pandemic, I strongly recommend you book with a trusted tour operator that offers flexible booking terms. Click the links below for details of dates, deposits and rebooking policies.

So which is the right island for you?

Happening islands with diversity

St Lucia is an island that many feel has it all. Unusually, its geography differs greatly from north to south, so much so that it’s possible to have a two-centre honeymoon on one island. The south is home to the majestic Pitons, lush rainforest, botanical gardens, a walk-in volcano, zip lines and mountain biking trails, plus very individual resorts like Anse Chastanet and Jade Mountain.

The north is more densely inhabited with more hotels, restaurants and bars around busy areas like Rodney Bay and its attractive Marina. St Lucia is a good choice for weddings, heritage, eating out and spas.

Jamaica is perhaps the most popular of all Caribbean islands, but often dismissed as somewhere that is spoilt or too mainstream, or even dangerous. In fact, it is a fabulously diverse island with long established five-star resorts like Half Moon Bay and Jamaica Inn, as well as funky hideaways like Strawberry Hills in the Blue Mountains.

Total romantic retreats

Anguilla is one of those tiny Caribbean islands that is a total escape from everyday life. It’s tiny with some of the most incredible white sand beaches in the world and a surprisingly happening food and party scene, perfect for chilling out and indulging. Top honeymoon resorts include Cap Juluca and CuisinArt Golf Resort & Spa.

If you have a healthy budget, the Caribbean is home to some exceptional private island resorts including Mustique in the Grenadines and Necker Island in the British Virgin Islands. Here honeymooners are treated like royalty.

Local colour and individual feel

Barbados remains one of the most popular islands for UK couples due to its very distinct island feel and good choice of hotels including some very individual hideaways such as The Atlantis and Little Good Harbour.

An alternative to busy islands and big resorts, check out St Kitts which has an “old school” vibe of plantation architecture, warm hospitality and toes-in-the-sand casual bars and restaurants. Best places to stay include Ottley’s Plantation Inn which has manicured gardens and  a lovely spa overlooking the rainforest.

Finding value for money

In the current climate, your honeymoon budget may be squeezed or you might just be looking for exceptional value for money. All-inclusive hotels are often a good solution. They may not be a budget option, but you certainly get a lot for your money and there are no extras to worry about on check out.

Secrets Royal Beach Punta Cana in the Dominican Republic is a great choice.

>> Now check out our detailed guide to the cost of a honeymoon in the Caribbean.

Find more all-inclusive honeymoons in the Caribbean. Visit our sister site, 101 Holidays, to find the best time to visit the Caribbean.

Last updated: 13 August 2021

Before you book

Travel guidelines and advice are changing constantly amid the Covid-19 pandemic. Check the latest travel restrictions for UK residents.